This is the third of these I have written and it is the one that is genuinely different.

When I wrote about working in Balwyn a week or two ago, I said the wardrobes out there are full of good clothes that do not talk to each other. Quality bought carefully, one sensible piece at a time, none of it combining.

St Kilda is the exact opposite, and I mean that almost precisely.

Amber in a black strapless maxi dress with a large pink and lilac rose print, worn with teal heels, beside a pool

The opposite problem

Open a wardrobe in St Kilda, Elwood or Balaclava and there is no shortage of personality in there. Vintage. Print. A coat somebody clearly loved choosing. Things with a point of view, bought because they were wonderful rather than because they were sensible.

And the woman standing next to me says she has nothing to wear, which sounds absurd until you look at what she actually reaches for, which is the same jeans and the same black top, five days a week, while all of it hangs there being marvellous.

The gap is not personality. It is the plain, hard-working middle. The well-cut trousers. The good white shirt. The knit that goes with everything. The jacket that is not a statement. The boring half of a wardrobe, which nobody enjoys buying and which is the entire reason the interesting half gets worn.

Without it, every interesting piece has to carry a whole outfit on its own. Some days you have the energy for that. Most Tuesdays you do not, so you put the jeans on again.

What that actually looks like

Here is the pattern, and I see it over and over.

There are usually four or five genuinely special things, each of which has nothing to go with it. A beautiful printed maxi with no plain tank. A vintage coat with nothing underneath that is calm enough to let it speak. A pair of extraordinary boots that only work with one skirt, and that skirt is wrong for work.

Then there is a large middle section of things that are almost right. Bought in the same spirit as the special pieces, but not quite as good, so they never get worn either. These are the expensive drag on the whole wardrobe.

And then there is the uniform. Jeans, black top, same boots. Which is a perfectly good uniform, except that it is not a choice, it is a default, and it is being worn by somebody who clearly has taste and would rather not.

Amber in a multicoloured zigzag knit bodycon mini dress with sunglasses, a burgundy crocodile-print cross-body strap and a turquoise chunky bracelet, on a gum-lined track

The fix is not toning it down

I want to be very clear about this, because it is what women in this part of town are afraid a stylist will do.

I am not going to take the personality out. If your clothes have a point of view, that is the most valuable thing in the wardrobe and it is the one thing you cannot buy quickly. It took years to develop and I am not going to replace it with a beige capsule because beige photographs well.

What makes a strong piece read as style rather than as effort is what sits next to it. One loud thing with calm around it looks deliberate. Three loud things at once looks like a theme. I wrote the long version of this out in how to do luxe boho, and the formula there is the same formula here: one hero, everything else quiet.

So the work is not subtraction. It is building the quiet, so the hero has somewhere to stand. That usually means buying four or five deliberately unexciting things, which is the least fun shopping trip of your life and the one that changes the most.

What I would never touch

People brace for this part, so let me say out loud what is safe.

The one coat. Nearly every wardrobe around here has a coat that is slightly too much and completely wonderful. Colour, cut, age, something. It stays. If it only gets worn six times a year, six times a year somebody tells you that you look incredible, and there is no basic on earth that does that.

Anything inherited. A thing that came from your mother or your grandmother is not competing with the rest of the wardrobe and should not be judged by the same rules. If it fits, we will find a way to wear it. If it does not, it is not clutter, it is an heirloom, and it belongs in a box rather than on a donation pile.

The pieces you light up about. I watch faces during a session far more than I watch garments. When somebody pulls something out and their voice changes, that garment has already passed. We are not discussing it. We are working out what it needs underneath.

Colour. Women get told to buy neutrals so often that they start to think wearing colour is an error of judgement. It is not. If you suit it and you love it, the neutrals are there to serve the colour, not to replace it.

What does go, if anything does, is the almost-right middle. The things bought in the same hopeful spirit as the special ones but a notch down, which never quite get worn and which quietly cost more than everything else combined. Nobody has ever missed one of those.

The boring list, which is the whole trick

If I had to write it down for you without ever seeing your wardrobe, it would be close to this.

  • Trousers that fit properly. Not jeans. Something with a bit of structure that you can wear with a printed top and look finished.
  • A white or cream shirt. Good fabric, correct sleeve length. It is the single most useful thing you can own next to a strong print.
  • One plain knit in a colour that suits you. Not black, unless black genuinely suits you. Something that will sit under a coat and over a dress.
  • A plain tank or fitted tee that actually works under the printed skirts you already own.
  • A jacket with no opinion. Denim, leather or a plain blazer. It is the thing that makes a wild dress wearable at eleven in the morning.

That is five pieces. None of them will excite you in the shop. Between them they will double the number of things in your wardrobe you can actually get out of the house in, which is the only number that matters.

Amber in a navy and white striped sequinned tee with a denim jacket tied at the waist, blue skinny jeans, a pale denim slouch bag and jewelled white flat sandals

Vintage, and when it is a trap

St Kilda and vintage go together, and I am not going to argue against it, because I own and wear genuine vintage myself.

The dress at the top of this piece is a 1970s floral maxi that came from my mum, who had the foresight to keep it and the generosity to hand it over. My eldest son once walked into my wardrobe with a pair of scissors and did his best to destroy it. A dressmaker repaired it so well that I could not find the seam afterwards. I still wear it.

So: vintage, yes. With two rules.

It has to fit through the shoulders. A waist can be taken in, a hem can come up, a sleeve can be shortened. Shoulders are the one thing that is difficult and expensive to change, and a jacket or dress that is wrong there will never sit right no matter what you pay somebody.

You have to want it for a Wednesday. The trap with vintage is buying the admiration rather than the garment. If the honest answer to “when would I wear this” is “somewhere, eventually, probably”, it is going to hang there with your other wonderful things. That is not a bargain, whatever it cost.

Where to shop around here

St Kilda itself is not really a clothes-shopping destination, and I would rather tell you that than pretend.

Acland and Fitzroy Streets are for eating, drinking and the walk. There are things worth finding, but you are not going there with a list of five basics and coming home satisfied.

The Esplanade market runs every Sunday along the Upper Esplanade, between Fitzroy Street and Acland Street, from ten in the morning. It is art, craft and design rather than clothing, so go for the jewellery, the atmosphere and the sea air, not for a wardrobe.

Chapel Street is ten minutes up the road and is where you actually go. The Prahran and Windsor ends in particular, which is where the vintage and the interesting independents are. I have written the whole strip up in the Chapel Street guide, including which end is for what.

Greville Street, Prahran is the serious vintage, and worth a dedicated trip rather than a wander.

The op shops through Balaclava and toward Elwood are very good and get overlooked because everyone drives east for op shopping. My op shopping guide has the method.

Honestly, for the boring list above, the most efficient trip is none of these. It is a plain, unglamorous hour somewhere with good basics and a changing room, and that is usually the shape a shopping day takes with a St Kilda client: twenty minutes of fun and two hours of foundations.

Amber in a white crochet lace sleeveless maxi cardigan over a blue paisley print romper, with tan gladiator sandals and a blue tassel necklace, on a jetty

What a session looks like

I will not do the whole walkthrough again, because it is on the stylist page and I wrote it out properly in the Balwyn piece.

The one thing that is different here is where the time goes. In the east, most of a session is spent finding combinations in a wardrobe that already contains everything it needs. In St Kilda, more of it is spent writing the shopping list, because the gap is real and it is not going to be solved by rearranging.

So expect to come out of a session with a short, specific, slightly dull list, and expect me to be quite firm about it. That list is the whole return on the afternoon.

Sessions are $299 for two hours, $549 for four and $799 for six, with the breakdown in what a personal stylist costs in Melbourne. Two hours is enough for most people.

Who this suits

You, if your wardrobe is more interesting than your week. If you own things you love and wear things you do not. If people have told you that you have great style and you privately feel like a fraud because you have been in the same jeans since March.

Also you, if your life has moved and the clothes have not. A new job with a dress code, a body that has changed, a stage where the going-out wardrobe outnumbers the actual going out by about nine to one. None of that is a failure of taste. It just means the wardrobe is answering a question you stopped asking.

Not you, if what you want is a makeover. I am not interested in turning you into somebody else, and frankly the raw material around here is better than most of what a makeover would replace it with.

Amber in a striped jersey maxi dress layered under a denim jacket with suede ankle boots, leaning against a blue and white bathing box

Starting

St Kilda, Elwood, Balaclava, Albert Park, Middle Park, South Melbourne, Windsor. Same session, same prices, no surcharge for the postcode.

If the five boring things above sound like exactly what you are missing, you probably already knew that, and you have probably been putting it off because it is not an exciting way to spend money. It is, however, the cheapest thing on this entire blog in terms of outfits gained per dollar, and if you want a plan rather than a shopping trip, the capsule wardrobe guide is free and will get you most of the way.

Otherwise, get in touch and tell me which part of your week is hardest to dress for. That one sentence tells me more than a photograph of the wardrobe ever does.

And now you’re Looking Good Girls.

“For we are God’s handiwork, created in Christ Jesus to do good works, which God prepared in advance for us to do.” Ephesians 2:10