Right, the west is in.

Which means I can finally write the Highpoint post, and I am glad, because it is the most interesting of these to write. Not because of the suburb, but because of the building.

Almost everything I have ever published about shopping assumes a strip: walk it slowly, go into the small shops, talk to somebody, buy nothing the first time. That advice is correct and at Highpoint it will ruin your afternoon. A centre that big is a different skill, with different rules, and nobody is ever taught either set.

So this one is for Maribyrnong, Moonee Ponds, Essendon, Footscray, Yarraville and Williamstown, and it is mostly about how to use the thing in the middle of it without losing a whole Saturday.

Amber in a khaki green long-sleeved top with camouflage-print drawstring track pants and cream lace-up ankle boots, in front of palms

What Highpoint actually is

For anybody who has somehow never been: Highpoint sits in Maribyrnong, about eight kilometres north west of the city, and it is one of the largest shopping centres in the country. Something close to 150,000 square metres of it, which is a number that means nothing until you are standing in the middle of it wondering where you parked.

Two department stores, the discount department stores, the supermarkets, a cinema, and the big international chains alongside a few hundred smaller shops. The centre’s own directory is worth a look before you go, and I mean that literally rather than as a throwaway, because looking at it on the couch for five minutes is the single highest-value thing you can do about a Highpoint trip.

What that scale gives you is range. You can replace an entire category in one afternoon. If you need five work tops in a size that is hard to find, this is where you go, and you will probably succeed.

What it takes away is discovery. You are not going to stumble on something wonderful in a shop you have never heard of, because the tenant mix is the same tenant mix as everywhere else, just more of it. That is not a criticism. It is simply what the format is for.

A big centre is the opposite skill to a strip

I wrote about shopping Camberwell a few weeks ago and the advice there was almost the reverse of this. On a strip you should walk it slowly, go into the small shops, talk to people and buy nothing the first time. Browsing is the point.

At Highpoint, browsing is the enemy.

The reason is simple arithmetic. On a strip you can see everything in an hour. Here you cannot see everything at all, so an unplanned trip is not thorough, it is random. You end up having looked at maybe a tenth of what is there, exhausted, and buying from that tenth as though it were the whole field.

And there is a specific trap that only happens in big centres. You find an acceptable version of the thing you came for in the second shop. It is fine. It is not right, but it is fine, and the thought of walking past another forty shops to find out whether something better exists is unbearable. So you buy the fine one. That is not a decision, that is fatigue, and it is how most of the almost-right things in most wardrobes got there.

The plan that makes it work

Four steps, and the third is the one people skip.

One: a written list, made at home. Not a mental list. Written. Categories and sizes, in order of how badly you need them. If you have had a wardrobe session the list already exists, which is most of what you are paying for.

Two: start at a specific shop, not at the entrance. Decide before you walk in where you are going first. Entering a centre this size without a destination is how the first forty minutes disappear.

Three: one lap, buying nothing. This is the step everyone skips and it is the one that works. Walk the relevant shops, try things on, note what is good and where, and buy none of it. You cannot judge the first acceptable version against anything until you have seen the field.

Four: go back for the ones that passed. Usually two or three things out of a dozen. Occasionally nothing, and that is a successful trip too, which is a thing nobody says out loud.

Amber in a bright ikat-print ruffled sundress with a blue satin waistband, sunglasses, a yellow cross-body bag and red patent platform heels, at a skatepark

Where the value actually is

Centres this size are not uniformly good. They are very good at some things and quite poor at others.

The discount department stores are for volume. Tees, leggings, sleepwear, socks, kids clothes, basics you will wash to death. Buy them here and do not agonise. That check shirt further down this post came from Big W years ago and it is one of the most worn things I have photographed.

The big internationals are for trend, for one season. The things you will love this summer and be finished with by the next. Pay accordingly, which is to say not much, and do not expect the fabric to survive.

The department stores are for fit. This is the real argument for Highpoint over a strip. A bra, a coat, a swimsuit, anything structured, anything where getting it wrong is expensive. These are the categories where somebody measuring you properly is worth more than any amount of browsing, and a department store is one of the few places left that will do it.

The smaller shops are for the one piece. If there is something in the middle of the price range you actually want to keep, it is usually in there rather than in an anchor.

What is almost never worth it is the impulse middle. The not-cheap, not-good thing bought at hour three. That is the category that quietly eats more money than everything else on this list combined, and I have written about why in how to shop smarter and stop wasting money on clothes.

Amber in a red, white and grey check shirt worn open over a grey marl mini skirt with black patent peep-toe heels, against a bluestone wall

The changing room is where the trip is won

A centre like this makes it very easy to buy without trying on, because the queues are long and you are tired and you can always return it. You will not return it. Almost nobody does. The bag sits in the boot for six weeks and then the window closes.

So: try everything on, every time, and take a photograph in the mirror of anything you are considering. Not because the photograph is flattering, it never is, but because it shows you the thing at arm’s length instead of at the distance your own eyes see it from, and that distance is where the mistakes hide.

What to look at while you are in there, in order, because most people check the wrong things.

Shoulders first. A shoulder seam that sits out past your own shoulder is the one fault a tailor cannot cheaply fix, and it is the fault that makes an expensive thing look borrowed. Everything else on a garment is negotiable. This is not.

Then sit down. Genuinely, in the cubicle. A skirt that works standing and rides up sitting is a skirt you will wear twice. Same with a waistband that is fine until you bend.

Then raise both arms. If the whole garment lifts with them, the armhole is cut too low for you and you will spend the day tugging it down.

Then look at where the hem lands. On a sleeve, at the wrist bone. On trousers, with the shoes you will actually wear, not the ones you have on. Hems are the cheapest thing to change and the most commonly left wrong.

Only after all of that is it worth asking whether you like it, and whether it earns its place, which is a separate test I set out properly in the cheap clothing stores guide.

The rest of the west, honestly

I am not going to give you a tour of western boutiques, because I would be making it up. I do not know the Footscray and Yarraville strips the way I know Chapel Street or Camberwell, and inventing a list would be worse than useless to you.

What I can tell you is the two things I would actually use out that way.

DFO Essendon, for last season at outlet prices. It is a genuinely good option if you want a coat or a label piece and you are relaxed about exactly which one. The full picture is in my outlet shopping guide.

The op shops, which in the west are underrated precisely because everybody drives east to op shop. Less picked over, for the same reason. My op shopping guide has the method for working a rack properly.

If you shop the west and you know the strips, tell me. I would genuinely rather learn it from someone who does than pretend.

What a personal shopper actually does at a centre like this

People picture somebody arriving with armfuls of clothes and a lot of opinions. It is much duller than that and much more useful.

I know where things are. That sounds trivial and it is most of the value. Knowing which shop carries a decent plain trouser in your size, on which level, saves the lap entirely. Half of what you are buying is somebody else having already done the walking.

I stop you buying the near-miss. This is the actual job. Not finding more, finding less. A good shopping day usually ends with fewer bags than you expected and a much higher proportion of things you will still be wearing in two years. If I have talked you out of three almost-right purchases, the day has paid for itself and we have not bought anything yet.

I make you try things you would walk past. Everybody has a rule about themselves that stopped being true some years ago. I do not wear prints. I cannot wear a crew neck. Nothing with a belt. Some of those rules are correct and some are a bad experience from 2014 that calcified, and a changing room is the only place to find out which.

I keep the order right. Underwear and the structured things first, while you are fresh and patient, because they are the ones that need real attention. The fun stuff last, when fatigue will not do any damage.

I handle the tiredness. Not a joke. The reason I insist on going early and on stopping for coffee at the right moment is that nearly every bad purchase I have ever seen was made by somebody who had been upright for too long.

What a session out west looks like

The order matters more than anything else here.

Wardrobe first, shopping second. A wardrobe session is where the list comes from, and a shopping day at Highpoint without a list is just an expensive wander with company. The session also, reliably, makes the list shorter. There is nearly always more in the wardrobe than the owner can see.

Sessions are $299 for two hours, $549 for four and $799 for six, with the full breakdown in what a personal stylist costs in Melbourne. A shopping day is $399 for a half day or $649 for a full one, and a half day is plenty for Highpoint if we have a list.

No surcharge for the west, and the wardrobe session happens at your place, not mine.

Amber in a blue and white pinstripe strappy sundress with floral embroidery at the hem, turquoise bracelets and navy glitter-bow espadrille wedges

How I would do a Highpoint day

Look at the directory the night before and decide your three shops. Park at the end nearest the first one and photograph where you parked, which sounds ridiculous until the moment it does not.

Go early. The centre is calmer, the changing rooms are free and your judgement is intact, which it will not be by two o’clock.

Do the lap. Buy nothing. Have a coffee and look at your notes, which is when the obvious answer usually appears.

Then go back and buy the two or three things that passed, and leave. Do not do a victory wander. The victory wander is where the impulse middle gets bought.

Amber from behind in a grey knit cardigan layered under a grey fur vest, with a patterned mini skirt, black tights and black quilted knee-high boots, beside the water

One more for Melbourne specifically: whatever you buy, check it layers, because you will be dressing for four kinds of weather in one day for most of the year. The rule I use is in how to layer an outfit, and it is shorter on top than underneath.

Starting

Maribyrnong, Moonee Ponds, Essendon, Footscray, Yarraville, Williamstown and the rest of the west. Same sessions, same prices, no surcharge for the postcode.

If Highpoint has beaten you a few times, that is not a shopping failure, it is a format that is genuinely hard to use well and that nobody explains. Get in touch and tell me which category keeps defeating you, and we will start there.

And now you’re Looking Good Girls.

“Better a patient person than a warrior, one with self-control than one who takes a city.” Proverbs 16:32